by lora on November 8, 2007 at 3:11 am
In this post I am going to try to be transparent about myself, and my shortcomings, in regard to being the “perfect homeschooling family”. I am not trying to be self-deprecating; I hope that my transparency will help someone else. I have recently come to see what a disservice I have done to my family by trying to attain the “perfect homeschooling family” status that is promoted. At each homeschooling convention I attended I was given a verbal checklist of what the perfect husband/father, wife/mother, and child should be. I have spent years in frustration with myself, wondering why I just couldn’t “do it all.” I see others whose homes are perfect, their kids look great… they seem to have it all. As a wife, it is painfully obvious to me that I have not matched up to the criteria that was put forth. Looking at the husbands of these families at the conventions… well they sure seem to be great leaders of their homes…. they seem to be so spiritual. Why couldn’t my husband just be like all of these other dads?
Then something began to happen. As I became closer to some of these families and their children began nearing adulthood… something happened. Some of these families fell apart. I know of at least 5 families in the last two years where things have gone really bad. Watching these families caused me to really begin to look at why they were falling apart and how to prevent it within my own family. One thing we learned from a small incident that we went through was the importance of communication. It is vital that our children understand the “why” behind our actions and decisions and if we are too proud or busy to take the time to be open about these things, we will breed rebellion.
I also noticed a common thread among these families: usually there was an expectation of perfection. When we expect perfection out of others, or even ourselves, we are being unfair. We are placing undue pressure on those around us when we expect them to fit into the model that a mere man has set up. I don’t typically expect perfection out of my children or husband, but I know that my expectations for what Gene “should” be have been unattainable. The list of standards for a “Godly” husband that has been set forth is unrealistic. That is because it is set up in a extra-Biblical, man-made system.
While many of the things that are touted are good things, no man can do them all. Each husband, wife, and child is a unique creation and is going to handle things in a unique way. While some husbands are outspoken and opinionated, others are quiet and reserved. Why should I expect my husband to respond like someone else’s? Is that fair to him? I should have recognized the unique way in which God created him, and not compared him to others. I know that I have been unfair to Gene and placed a mantle upon his shoulders that God did not give him to bear.
Unrealistic expectations have a very real and detrimental side effect… anger. When perceived expectations and standards aren’t met, anger follows, and it can destroy a family. We have had a couple of very difficult situations that were forced upon us dealing with the anger within another family. The result was devastating and the fallout can have eternal consequences.
I see one simple way to prevent a great deal of this thinking, which is to stop relying on man, and to turn back to God’s Word. We are living in an age where we have the need to hear from an “expert” on every topic. We buy books and tapes with the expectation that this “expert” will have the answer we need. We have become so dependent upon the experts that we are unlikely to seek out the truth of God’s word for ourselves. It seems as if we don’t trust that the Holy Spirit the Lord has given to each of His servants will lead us on the path the Lord would have us to follow. Our family is in a place of truly trying to seek out what God’s direction is for us, and to accomplish what He has for us. This has meant that we are putting aside much of the traditional thought, seeking where the truth lies. This does not mean that we don’t seek advice from others, but we weigh the advice we are given against what the Lord has been showing us.
My hope and prayer is that each family will seek for themselves what God’s will is for them, and that we will love our family members for who they are in Christ, not placing our expectations on them.
Other articles in this series:

Patty — November 8, 2007 @ 8:59 am
As a mom of now grown children, we homeschooled for 17 years, I can so relate to what you write. We had so many families in our homeschool group that let you know just how perfect they were and strangly, those were the families that fell apart as the children grew towards adulthood, suffering problems as great or greater than the “world”.
We were considered a bit liberal in our thinking by these folks at the time because we didn’t stick to what the experts told us about raising our family, we prayed, let God direct and made mistaks along the way, told our children we made mistakes etc and now we are blessed with the most wonderful adult children that are not paying high prices for choices made in anger and rebellion.
Marci — November 8, 2007 @ 9:06 am
Great post!! I see the same thing you are talking about. We have gone through some hard times in our home. It was when we got real and truly communicated with our son and got on our face before God that things turned around.
Lisa — November 8, 2007 @ 12:00 pm
Another great post.
You might be interested in a post I did recently “A Christian Mother’s version of PERFECT MADNESS ” For some reason I can’t get blogger to give me a link to the exact post. Just scroll down to it.
Brea from Texas — November 9, 2007 @ 6:34 am
Wonderful post!! Completely true. Have you read Mike Pearl’s series titled ‘Jumping Ship’? (http://www.nogreaterjoy.org/topics/general-view/archive/2005/may/09/jumping-ship/) He speaks about the same issue. It’s a long read (it has 5 parts), but an amazing one.
I just realized you live in Katy! I lived there until I turned 18, and moved to Austin. I grew up in Old Katy; my dad live on Avd D and Morton, and my mom lives just behind Katyland. What a small world!!
Brea from Texas — November 9, 2007 @ 7:52 pm
Lora, I laughed when I read your comment, because we did have guineas!! I am a total guinea expert now, but we don’t have them anymore. Because we raised them from keets (chicks) to be pets, they were a little too friendly with our neighbors, and would go sit on the neighbor’s patio furniture and … ahem … POO ON EVERYTHING!! It wasn’t pretty … literally!
So now we just have the chickens. Hopefully, one day, we’ll have a bigger and more isolated piece of land, and we’ll be able to have them again.
I look forward to checking out that link, but I should probably clarify something. When it comes to our kids and the people we choose to become friends with now (like our amazing church!!), we try to be as like-minded as possible. It just bugs me when grown-ups drop old friends just because they don’t all fit in that lovely cookie cutter shape. My BF and I have been close since sophomore year in high school, and have very rare physical contact with her; she lives in New Orleans and doesn’t visit hardly ever. I’m sure our relationship would be different if she lived closer and was around my friends. I have other very close friends who are on the same page, theologically, as I am.
But yes, my kids are in contact with the people that we choose, who choose us, for beliefs we all share. My kids are 5, 4, and 1, though, so that will change as they get older … under our guidance, of course.
Thanks for commenting!! Look forward to ’seeing’ you around.
In Christ, ~Brea, the tinymama
Amanda Axelby — November 11, 2007 @ 2:51 pm
I totally relate to this post. It reminds me of the verse where Paul rebukes the believers for saying they follow Appollos, Peter and others follow his teachings. We are always ready to follow SOMEONE, not Jesus Himself. Unfortunately, we are all very human and often fall into this at some time. It is very freeing to know we have the Bible as our guide, not always another family; though it is good to have advice from older, more experienced believers, we just need to be careful to not put them in Jesus’ place.
Blessings to you and your family from an Australian mum.
Mrs. M — November 11, 2007 @ 4:25 pm
Thanks for posting this…perfect timing for me. I can see much of myself in what you said. The expectations always lead to anger and judgement.
marian — November 11, 2007 @ 7:14 pm
Hi. I’m visiting via Amy’s Humble Musings.
This post is so full of truth. My eldest child has many special needs, which are behavioral, cognitive, emotional, psychological and social. Following his implosion in Christian school, we became a homeschooling family, and it’s tough to walk daily in this, let alone meet the needs of all of my other children.
I have struggled to find a place to feel comfortable and be real in the homeschooling community. With the challenges we face daily affecting the whole family we haven’t a chance in the world to look like those Convention Families, no matter what we do. My child’s disabilities are not necessarily indicated by his physical appearance, so there is also no visible “explanation” for all of the many ways we do not “measure up”.
I have always rejected the idea that we must grind our own wheat, wear dresses, eschew any T.V., etc. etc etc etc, and can bear any peer pressure to do those things and any judgment coming along those lines. It’ still takes a certain continual putting-off of those expectations, but at least you can find others who practice as you do.
But when it comes to the behavior of my children, the atmosphere of my home, the emotional energy I have, and the academic achievements of my children (all of which are affected heavily by the one child), my heart is left open to the scorn of others when we’re so short of perfection, because I DO desire those things to be good. The anger and the impossible pressure on the children can be overwhelming and very destructive. It’s as if those I carry those Others always on my shoulder, with their standards and judgement.
The ONLY thing that produces good in our unique family is, as you said, seeking out God directly for what HE wants our homeschool, family, and expectations to look like. I am constantly having to re-direct my mind and heart to that place. God has unique puposes for each person and each family. WHy in the world WOULD He have a cookie-cutter approach. It is just SO like us humans to want to substitue a set of man-made rules as a boundary for who’s holy and who’s not, as a means of self -justification instead of Christ alone. It’s just especially insidious when it’s cloaked in Christianity and practices that, objectively speaking, are good– just not all meant for everyone. I’m sure Satan is thrilled with this dynamic.
Oh, gracious. I’m SO sorry to have turned this into a novel! (I don’t have an active blog now, or I’d just develop it into a post.) Anyway, thanks for the post, and I sincerely encourage you in your quest to seek out God’s vision for your uniqe family!
Jennifer Dages — November 11, 2007 @ 7:57 pm
AGain you are so right. I know this is a tempation to me at times. I do have a wonderful husband and I am grateful for him. AT time though I probably have unrealistic expectations of him and of myself. It is alot about growing in maturity and knowing what are non-negotiables and what aren’t.